Most rewatchable episode of S5: The finalists

As I said in the comments earlier, S5 is kind of uneven to me. Some of the best episodes (IMHO) of the series are in here, but I imagine watching The End, and being completely blown away, and then next week you get… Fallen Idols? Paris Hilton? Seriously? Or watching Sam Interrupted, with the boys being committed to a mental hospital because they’re telling the truth, and Dean’s real actual details about his life being the signs of some serious mental health issues, and drugged Sam booping Dean’s nose? All of which is kind of wonderful? And then next week you get Swap Meat. Talk about whiplash.

Anyway. There are many wonderful episodes in this season, and now we need to pick the one we like to rewatch the most. (Note that this doesn’t mean your favorite episode. Some people, for example, love Swan Song but can’t bear to rewatch it.)

And the finalists are…

( Take the poll... )